Striving to remove barriers that prevent us from building Vibrant, Diverse, Inclusive, Accessible Communities!

 

Judy Heumann: Tenacious Symbol

Line art portrait of a smiling middle aged woman with glasses and shoulder length hair, framed by red and blue stars and stripes.
Judy Heumann, disability rights leader and cofounder of Disabled in Action, who led the 1977 San Francisco occupation that forced the federal rules implementing Section 504. Published with the article in The American Prospect.

Polio reached Judy Heumann in 1949, before her second birthday, and she spent the following five decades removing barriers that had closed American public life to People with Disabilities. New York City public schools had never employed a teacher who used a wheelchair until she became one in 1970, and as cofounder and president of Disabled in Action she converted her own exclusion into organized community power. Nathan Tankus, whose aunt Frieda Tankus cofounded that same organization as its vice president and was 22 when complications from a spinal operation ended her life, argues that Heumann's standing as the movement's central figure cannot be separated from the organizers who never lived long enough to see results. Exclusion shortens lives, which is why so few of Heumann's closest colleagues reached their sixties, and her recognition works as representation for ordinary people who fought hard and were never named.

The movement Heumann led borrowed its methods directly from the civil rights movement, and its victories came through confrontation rather than polite request. Members of Disabled in Action brought Manhattan traffic to a standstill during peak evening hours in November 1972 after the Rehabilitation Act was vetoed, and they positioned their wheelchairs in front of city buses to remove the barrier of a transit system with no lifts. That escalation peaked in 1977, when Heumann led a 26 day occupation of a federal Department of Health, Education, and Welfare building in San Francisco after officials refused to write the rules that would put Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 into practice. No takeover of a United States federal building has since lasted longer without violence, and the Black Panthers backed those occupiers without hesitation or reservation, which shows that the first genuine federal step forward for People with Disabilities, and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) that followed in 1990, were won together with Black organizers rather than apart from them.

When enforceable protections are taken away, People with Disabilities are left holding nothing but the goodwill of whoever happens to be in charge, and Heumann spent her life demonstrating that goodwill has never been enough.

Heumann carried the same fight inside institutions, working to develop what became the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) as a Senate staffer in 1974, serving as deputy director of the Center for Independent Living so People with Disabilities could live in their own homes by choice, and later pressing disability rights onto the global agenda through the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. Yet how precarious all of it remains showed plainly in February 2020, when the Museum of Modern Art premiered a documentary about the disability rights movement and had built no ramp to its stage, not even a temporary one, so Heumann and other wheelchair users were raised by a hand cranked lift at an excruciating pace while the audience waited. Community Builders should read that scene exactly as it stands: exclusion is manufactured by the planning decisions of hosts, never by anyone's disability, and a venue that honors this movement while stranding its honorees below the stage has failed the very people it claims to celebrate. Before booking your next gathering, walk the route a wheelchair user would take to the podium and to the seating, put a request list for accessibility services directly on the invitation, and confirm every requested service is in place before the doors open, because Vibrant, Diverse, Inclusive, Accessible Communities for People with Disabilities are built by planning that removes barriers before the event opens rather than apologizing for them afterward.

We should remember the organizers, like Frieda Tankus, whose work built the movement even when they did not live to see its gains. We should defend enforceable protections for People with Disabilities, because goodwill alone has never been enough. Gatherings planned so every honoree can reach the stage would move us toward Vibrant, Diverse, Inclusive, Accessible Communities for People with Disabilities.

Read the Full Article: Judy Heumann: Tenacious Symbol.
By: Nathan Tankus

Questions for Reflection

  1. Who are the unnamed organizers in the disability rights history of our community, and how do we remember them?
  2. Which protections for People with Disabilities in our community rest on law, and which only on goodwill?
  3. Before our next event, have we walked the route a wheelchair user would take to the stage?
  4. What did the 26 day occupation in San Francisco show about movements working together?
  5. How do we make sure the people we honor can reach the stage where we honor them?

Share or Print with:

Share

“My white cane, for almost any crew I encountered, was a symbol of not being able to do anything.” -Michelle Guadalupe Felix Garcia, Let’s Add Accessibility to the Mix


Explore More Compelling Insights:

Learn about topics related to People with Disabilities, Accessibility, Anti-Ableism, Removing Barriers, and the Disability Community? Tap the Explore button to discover something new and intriguing with each tap!